Topics: June 2023, Spirituality | Indigenous

Why more Indigenous people are leaving Christianity

"I just realized that it’s so much bigger than this white man’s church,” says one Ojibwe woman of losing her religion

The number of Indigenous people in Cana­da who identify as Christian fell from 63 percent in 2011 to 47 percent in 2021, according to the latest census data. (Illustration: Romain Lasser)

“I realized that there is something out there. But what’s out there isn’t what we’ve been taught in the residential schools, even on the reserves with mission­aries; that’s not it. What’s out there is the Creator and our ancestors and all of our spirits,” recalls Elizabeth Hawk­smith, an Ojibwe woman who grew up in Sarnia, Ont.

Though her parents raised her as a Christian, Hawksmith found mean­ing in stories shared by her grandfather, an Indian day school survivor, and in the process lost her religion.

She also found a sense of belonging and identity in her family’s cultural her­itage after feeling estranged from God, Jesus, her church community and more religious members of her family who rejected her bisexuality. “I just realized that it’s so much bigger than this white man’s church,” she says. “And I realized I could never go back.”

Want more from BroadviewSubscribe to our weekly newsletter!

Hawksmith walked away from the United Church, and she’s not alone. The number of Indigenous people in Cana­da who identify as Christian fell from 63 percent in 2011 to 47 percent in 2021.

A deeper dive into the latest census data shows that Indigenous people are leaving the church at a higher rate than the general population. Almost half of Indigenous people do not identify as being affiliated with any religion at all, a 16 percent increase from 2011. Another emerging trend is the practice of Indig­enous spirituality, with the number of participants rising by almost 25 percent since 2011. The figures suggest that the path out of churches for some Indigenous people is along “the red road” — meaning a traditional Indigenous spiritual path.

Some non­-Indigenous people are en­gaging in Indigenous spiritual practices too. Of the 80,690 people who told the census they follow Indigenous spiritu­ality, about four percent do not identify as Indigenous.

The number of Indigenous people leaving the church has been growing, but so has the Indigenous population in Canada overall. It rose to 1.8 million in 2021, an almost 10 percent increase from 2016 (compared to just a five­ percent increase in the non­Indigenous population). Birth rates aren’t the only factor affecting the size of the popula­tion: Indigenous people are now more likely to self­-identify as Indigenous on the census form.

More on Broadview:

It’s a phenomenon known as re­sponse mobility — when people give dif­ferent responses about their Indigenous identity to the census over time. When they self-­identify, we get a clearer picture of the practices of Indigenous people be­cause their practices are linked to their Indigenous identity. These changes in identification can be related to newly discovered ancestry or the way ques­tions are worded, among other reasons.

Another factor that may be contrib­uting to the return to traditional prac­tices is that Indigenous people are more likely to live in multigenerational house­holds, providing more opportunities for sharing cultural teachings and practices across generations.

From a statistical perspective, the movement of Indigenous people away from Christianity is a noticeable shift. And on an individual level, Hawksmith can feel a difference too. “I feel a lot lighter. When I’m actually praying for something, somebody’s listening. And when I need guidance, there’s a lot of people that are there behind me, a lot of spirits trying to help,” she says. “I can even feel it when I make a mistake. Literally all of the aunties behind me are like, ‘What are you doing?’ They’re just shaking their heads,” her voice smiles.

She might have lost her religion, but she has found her spirit in the process.


Alison Tedford Seaweed is a freelance writer, business consultant, author and member of Kwakiutl First Nation.

This story first appeared in Broadview’s June 2023 issue’s Religion in Canada series with the title “Coming Home to Spirit.”

We hope you found this Broadview article engaging. 

Our team is working hard to bring you more independent, award-winning journalism. But Broadview is a nonprofit and these are tough times for magazines. Please consider supporting our work. There are a number of ways to do so:

  • Subscribe to our magazine and you’ll receive intelligent, timely stories and perspectives delivered to your home 8 times a year. 
  • Donate to our Friends Fund.
  • Give the gift of Broadview to someone special in your life and make a difference!

Thank you for being such wonderful readers.

Jocelyn Bell



Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

  • says:

    She didn't lose her religion- she returned to the Spirit Faith of her people. The Protestant church is painfully beginning to shift to the same ethos as it dies in the past. Rohr wrote a book based on the New Testament, THE UNIVERSAL CHRIST. It echoes the central faith of Buddhism & Hindu faith; That centrals stress on " the Spirit in me greets the Spirit in you; Presence one to another; Life flowing one to another. Basic Indigenous Faith.

  • says:

    I agree with Stan. These people are turning away from "christianity" (lower case on purpose). They are not turning away from religion. "Indigenous spirituality" is a religion.
    What they are doing is changing "gods"

  • says:

    Living in the Spirit. This is what God/Creator wants us to do. I hope you will grow in the Spirit and share your peace and love among all the people you meet. Do not be sidelined by labels and categories put upon you. Indigenous spiritual practices existed before christianity.
    The Gospel of John does warn us, John 4.3
    "And every spirit that confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is not of God and this is that spirit of antichrist where of ye have heard that it should come and even now already is it in the world." Peoples' holy spirit has been ravaged, hurt, damaged, controlled by alcohol, drugs, punctured by hate, and self loathing. Only we as individuals can surpass this pain by living in the Spirit.