Woman with ginger hair cut into a bob. She is wearing a blue blouse with a long gold chain.
Broadview editor and publisher Jocelyn Bell. (Photo: Regina Garcia)

Topics: Oct/Nov 2022, UCC in Focus | Editor's Letter

This is a time for the United Church to listen

Carmen Lansdowne's election suggests the denomination has come a long way on reconciliation, but there is still a lot of work ahead


Many moons ago, at age 11, I attended The United Church of Canada’s 31st General Council. These national meetings of the denomination happen every three years and are a time when big decisions are made and future paths are charted.  

Being a kid, I was part of the “Children at Council” program. It was much like a day camp designed to occupy us while our parents voted on matters before the national church. There was a clown, ice cream cups and lots of songs with actions.

Easily the most significant event at that 1986 gathering was the church’s apology to Indigenous peoples for its part in colonization. While I remember witnessing this historic event, it took decades longer for me to understand its magnitude. The apology that day was acknowledged but not accepted: the Indigenous church is still waiting for the rest of the church to live out its words.

This year, the national church met again for the 44th General Council — this time online and spread over several months, rather than the traditional week in person. Broadview covers this meeting because we are affiliated with The United Church of Canada. We are editorially independent, but the denomination gives us an annual grant and many of our subscribers and donors are United Church members.

Interested in more stories like this? Subscribe to Broadview’s weekly newsletter.

One of the most significant decisions of this year’s meeting was to elect Rev. Carmen Lansdowne as moderator, the church’s spiritual leader. Lansdowne, who graces our cover and is profiled in the issue, is the first Indigenous woman to serve as moderator, and only the second Indigenous moderator in the church’s 97-year history. To meet the demands of the job, she is taking a three-year leave from her position as executive director of First United Church Community Ministry Society, a multifaceted outreach to street-affected people in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside. 

People in the church often say that the General Council elects the moderator it needs. I believe that to be true in Lansdowne’s case, especially given the recent confirmation of unmarked graves at church-run residential schools. Her election suggests that the United Church has come a long way in its journey toward reconciliation and is perhaps drawing closer to living out its 1986 apology. 

More on Broadview:

But it’s important to temper that hope with a realistic view of the work ahead. The church continues to struggle with racism, colonialism, white privilege and their associated issues. Lansdowne speaks to this in her vision statement for the church: “Can we pivot in a three-year period and shed our colonial baggage, solving all of our societal, political, economic or environmental problems? No.” 

The church, however, can listen, discern, pray, listen again and try to keep setting its feet on the path toward reconciliation, toward living out its apology. As Lansdowne writes: “Being an intercultural church together means that we are radically committed to community, to granting each other dignity and listening to each other in ways that transform who each of us is and who we are together.”


Jocelyn Bell is the editor-publisher of Broadview.

This editorial first appeared in Broadview’s October/November 2022 issue with the title “A time to listen.”

We hope you found this Broadview article engaging. 

Our team is working hard to bring you more independent, award-winning journalism. But Broadview is a nonprofit and these are tough times for magazines. Please consider supporting our work. There are a number of ways to do so:

  • Subscribe to our magazine and you’ll receive intelligent, timely stories and perspectives delivered to your home 8 times a year. 
  • Donate to our Friends Fund.
  • Give the gift of Broadview to someone special in your life and make a difference!

Thank you for being such wonderful readers.

Jocelyn Bell



Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

  • says:

    Correct me if I'm wrong. You cannot live out an apology.
    Once you apologize, you have addressed the issue, it is up to the other party to accept or reject the apology. (Which is forgiveness - Christ addresses that quite often.)
    One can (try to) live out repentance, but an unforgiving person(s) won't accept your repentance either.
    Unforgiveness is the recipients sin not yours.

    Being a Body of Christ's Believers should transform us, not
    so much a community group.
    Without Christ you can do nothing. John 15:5

  • says:

    As an independent paper greatly dependent on the UCC's financial support you ought to tell the whole truth about alleged unmarked graves in its full context and the UCC ought to make its financial support dependent upon objective journalistic integrity.