The writer and her Oma. (Photo courtesy Anne Bokma)

Topics: Ethical Living | Opinion

I don’t want to be a grandmother

Babies born today will endure the devastating effects of climate change, and grandparents won't be able to protect them

 | 

This confession is not going to make me popular. My kids may not like it. If you’re a grandparent, you might not either.

I don’t want to be a grandmother.

It’s not vanity.

It’s not because I’m turning 60 this year and the idea of being a grandma reinforces just how old I really am.

It’s not because my daughters, Ruby, 24, and Lucy, 21, are too young to have kids — as recent university grads, they are still finding their footing.

It’s because this world, as beautiful as it can be, is entirely too inhospitable for any future potential grandchildren I might have.

My Oma was 29 when she delivered my mother in her own bed in 1944 in the Netherlands while German bombs rained down during the Second World War.

My mother was just 18 when she delivered me in 1962, alone in a hospital room, just before the Cuban Missile Crisis brought the U.S. and the Soviet Union to the brink of war.

When I delivered my firstborn at 35 and my second daughter at 38, there were conflicts all around the world, from riots in Northern Ireland to civil wars in Iraq, Afganistan, Sierra Leone and Chechnya, among other places.
We are all born into war.

But by far the biggest and deadliest war — the one that makes me despair for the kind of world any future grandchildren of mine would inherit — is the war we humans are currently waging with our planet, which is on track to be ravaged by climate change in the coming decades. The United Nations has sounded a  “code red for humanity” after 234 of the world’s leading scientists from 66 countries delivered the most crucial report card on climate change last year, a 3,900-page document that gives humanity a great big F for screwing up the Earth for future generations. The climate emergency is deepening into a climate catastrophe. Some say an apocalypse.

Do I want my grandchildren living in an apocalyptic world? Absolutely not.


Interested in more stories like this? Subscribe to Broadview’s weekly newsletter.


Global warming levels are set to pass the crucial 1.5 C limit by the early 2030s, setting us on a path for increasingly severe climate disruptions. As temperature rises and weather patterns change, the spread of disease, harmful air pollutants, and food insecurity will be rampant. Children born today will face two- to seven times as many climate disasters as their grandparents did, including wildfires, storms, floods, and droughts. Imagine your grandchild not being able to play outside because of wildfire smoke that will make it hard for them to breathe. Or going hungry and thirsty because of a scarcity of food and water.

Any baby born in North America today will be enduring the devastating effects of climate change throughout their childhood and young adulthood. How will we, as grandparents, protect them? We can’t.

That’s why the dream of being a grandmother (and make no mistake — it would be the most wonderful dream to hold a child of my child in my arms) seems more like a nightmare to me.

My ex, the father of our daughters, is an eternal optimist who doesn’t believe in focusing on the negative.

“Relax,” he says. “People had children during the Ice Age. The glaciers have melted before, and people survived.”

I envy him his lack of worry.

And yet when we married in 1986, we were both firm in our resolve not to have children. The world was overpopulated, we said. Having children was an exercise in narcissism, we said. When our friends had kids, we publicly adored their progeny but privately wondered about the wisdom of bringing more people into the world.

 

 

View this post on Instagram

 

A post shared by The Years Project (@yearsofliving)

That is, until I turned 34 and woke up one morning with an intense longing that was entirely new to me – I wanted a baby. Right then and there. My principles flew out the window – as did the birth control we had used faithfully for 15 years.

Often there is no logic to our actions. We fervently believe one way, then act another way entirely.

There’s hope for the future, you say. If we just keep up our fastidious recycling and hang our wash out to dry, we’ll be fine, right? No, we won’t. These things are a mere trifle in comparison to the kind of actions that are required if we have any hope of preserving the planet — the biggest of which is not having children and grandchildren who will go on to produce a lifetime of carbon emissions that will contribute to the climate emergency. A child born into the developed world leaves a 58.6-metric-tonne carbon footprint annually, according to a study published in Environmental Research LettersNext to not having kids, the best things we can do for the planet are to live car-free, avoid air travel and eat a plant-based diet. All of which are a lot more difficult than simply switching to LED bulbs.

There are plenty of people who are having fewer kids or no kids at all in order to do their part to reduce global warming. New York Democratic representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has questioned whether childbearing is morally acceptable. “There’s a scientific consensus that the lives of children are going to be very difficult. And it does lead, I think, young people to have a legitimate question: Is it okay to still have children?” she said on Instagram.

Members of groups such Extinction Rebellion, BirthStrike and Stophavingkids.org are vocal about not having kids as a way to bring attention to the severity of the ecological crisis. Then there’s the “antinatalist” movement, which promotes the idea that having children is morally wrong because this life is nothing but a vale of tears.

But while you can be childless by choice, you can’t be grandchildless by choice. That’s up to your kids.

I wish I could be more like my friend Maggie, who revels in the bliss of her three grandchildren. “I can’t think about the planet blowing up in 100 years,” she says. “I think about today and how much joy they bring into my life.”

Is our desire to have grandchildren inherently selfish? It is driven by evolutionary biology? A desire to give and receive love? Can all three be true at the same time?


More on Broadview:


Is it supremely heretical to expect my daughters to be deprived of the experience of motherhood, an experience that has given me the greatest joy in life?

I think the answer to that would be yes.

The writer Gore Vidal recalled his grandfather saying: “Never have children, only grandchildren.”

He was referring to the unique bond grandparents have with their grandchildren, a bond that can surpass the relationship they have with their own kids. In fact, a study examining grandmothers’ brain functions suggests they may be more emotionally connected to grandchildren than their own children.

I think this was true for me and my Oma. She could be tough on my mom when she was growing up, but she doted on me. She loved me unreservedly and I adored her. I sat on her lap after Sunday night family dinners (while my Opa read the Bible) until I turned 12 years old and reluctantly realized I was too long and lanky to do that anymore.

There’s no question grandmothers can be a great gift in their grandchildren’s lives. It will be up to my children, of course, to determine if that’s a gift I will ever get to experience.

But if I don’t get the chance, I can’t say I’ll be sorry.

***

Anne Bokma is a writer in Hamilton, Ont.


We hope you found this Broadview article engaging. 

Our team is working hard to bring you more independent, award-winning journalism. But Broadview is a nonprofit and these are tough times for magazines. Please consider supporting our work. There are a number of ways to do so:

  • Subscribe to our magazine and you’ll receive intelligent, timely stories and perspectives delivered to your home 8 times a year. 
  • Donate to our Friends Fund.
  • Give the gift of Broadview to someone special in your life and make a difference!

Thank you for being such wonderful readers.

Jocelyn Bell

Editor/Publisher

Comments

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.


  • says:

    For those who think Jesus was a philosopher "Therefore do not be anxious about tomorrow, for tomorrow will be anxious for itself. Sufficient for the day is its own trouble."
    "Climate Change" is the result of a fallen world due to sin.
    We need to remember God is in control not science.
    "All the inhabitants of the earth are accounted as nothing, and he does according to his will among the host of heaven and among the inhabitants of the earth; and none can stay his hand or say to him, “What have you done?”"
    Remember we were created and commanded to be fruitful and multiply.
    "Like arrows in the hand of a warrior, so are children born in one’s youth. Blessed is the man whose quiver is full of them."
    Enjoy the years of your offspring, the memory lasts with them after you're gone.

  • says:

    I was feeling mildly optimistic about the possibility of turning things around before it is too late and then Russia attacked Ukraine and upset the applecart for everyone. Now, the rare opportunities I have to see or interact with my own five beautiful grandchildren are shadowed by a fearful dread of what is coming. Two of my daughters are threatened by major wildfires every year and another lives a five minute walk from the western edge of the Abbotsford flood. It is imperative that we hold our leaders to account for putting the environment first and our media for communicating the terrible cost of not taking action now.

  • says:

    Every child that is born comes with the message that God is not yet discouraged of man. Rabindranath Tagore

  • says:

    I disagree with Anne Bokma. There is an ecological crisis but I believe individuals need to make their own choices about having children. Look at the research and the positive actions of today’s children and grandchildren. We do need to “clean up” our act to cooperate with the Earth. However we need to leave fear behind and at the same time work together for a more sustainable world. What about another article on what progress we are making?