Until American right-wing activist Charlie Kirk was assassinated, I had no idea who he was, but I certainly do now. His over five-hour memorial service, attended by 60,000 in person and millions online, dominated just about every news media space we have. Even Canadian MPs stood up to show their support during a session of parliament. But if you had criticisms or questions of Kirk’s record, as Canadian journalist Rachel Gilmore does, then you opened yourself up to threats of rape and death.
What exactly are we dealing with, when vigils for this man are held across our own country and around the world?
You may unsubscribe from any of our newsletters at any time.
It means that we are facing a theocracy, with Trump as its leader and the tragically murdered Kirk as its sacrificial lamb. In his speech at the funeral, Trump called Kirk “the greatest evangelist for American liberty… a martyr now for American freedom.” He added, Kirk’s “name will live forever in the eternal chronicle of America’s greatest patriots. He will live forever.” We thought theocracies existed only in places like Iran, but we are seeing one emerging in the United States in real time.
We shouldn’t be surprised. Fascism, this time draped in a cross, is the logical outcome of neoliberal economics. This system outsourced and offshored well-paying manufacturing jobs, disenfranchising millions of people, leaving them to fend for themselves in the new gig economy. At the same time, obscene amounts of wealth were delivered into the hands of the few and a new aristocracy was created.
As has happened in other times in history, the extreme right swooped in and offered enemies to blame. And as in those other times, the centre-left seemed tone-deaf to ordinary people’s plights and incapable of addressing their legitimate fears and concerns.
More on Broadview:
- Are controversial monuments making a comeback?
- South Asians face rising hate in Canada
- RFK Jr.’s views on autism aren’t just wrong — they’re dangerous
Nor should we comfort ourselves that we are safe up here in Canada. The “Maple MAGA” movement is alive and well, and gaining strength as it exerts its influence in all levels of political and cultural life.
I recently interviewed American theologian and writer Danté Stewart about his Sept. 15 Substack article, “Notes from a Concerned American.” In the piece, he writes:
“And yet, I wrestle this morning with the question Fady Joudah, the poet, has asked: what do the slain teach?
That America will declare a war on everything and everyone except white supremacy.
Below: Christopher White interviews Danté Stewart
That America has a kind of selective outrage and empathy. That the country wants you to mourn a racist but not children being bombed in Gaza. That the country wants you to be angry when Charlie Kirk is killed but wants you to feel or say nothing when Rep. Melissa Hortman and husband are slain.”
We cannot pretend any longer that the world will somehow snap back to what we knew as normal. We are living in a new historic moment, and it is happening at a speed that is almost paralyzing.
But we are not powerless. We can act and resist. That means speaking out, taking risks as things get worse and accepting the enormity of the challenge.
***
Rev. Christopher White is a United Church minister in Hamilton.
Thanks for reading
Independent journalism rooted
in faith and justice is under threat
Broadview is the only media organization in Canada offering thoughtful, values-driven journalism from an inclusive, progressive Christian perspective. But our work depends on your support. If you value what you've just read, please act now.
A gift today helps keep this journalism alive tomorrow.
With gratitude,
Christopher,
Your first mistake is extreme name calling. America is far from a fascist state, as much as left-wing view the matter to be so.
Personally, I think “Trumpism” is a knee jerk reaction of Democratic policies over the years. I did follow Charlie Kirk and most of what he said had truth to it. His main concern was the indoctrination by liberal colleges and universities that were anti-Christian. He emphasized that most college degrees were a waste of taxpayers money. (Never graduating in college before, he somewhat proved that money could be made without a degree). Most issues he dealt with were challenges against popular thought. Perhaps confrontational, his “Prove me wrong” debates held weight. If one had a valid rebuttal he at least acknowledged it. I will admit after Trump’s second term in office, Kirk tended to be more extreme in his views.
But you do prove one of his points, you speak against extremism, but you quote “But we are not powerless. We can act and resist. That means speaking out, taking risks as things get worse and accepting the enormity of the challenge.” Is that not extremism? As Christians do we see the world getting better as Christ predicted? Please read Matthew 24 and let us know how you interpret the passage.
Thanks
If I compare Germany in the 1930s and 1940s and US in 2025, I do see a lot of parallels. History has called Germany under Hitler a Fascist state. It did not become so overnight. If you agree that it was Fascist and review the activities that occurred to make it so, I cannot believe that you cannot see those same types of activities happening in the US. Matthew 24 speaks of end times. Fascism in Germany spelled end times for Hitler’s Germany. It seems that whether you call it Fascist or not any violent destruction of those in compromised positions by those with extreme power who show little concern or compassion mark end times for those exercising that power. A thorough reading of the Bible shows a God who is parent and creator of all and exercises discipline for all humanity ‘Christian’ ‘Jew’ Muslim’ or other. End times happen to all who would thwart the Love and Compassion the true Ruler intends. Many countries are steering towards these end times. US and its MAGA is on a slippery path to its end times.
I could also compare the Book of Judges and North America in 2025. There are more than a lot of parallels. North America did not become this overnight either, and I refuse to believe that those same activities are not happening here and now. God ended Israel’s debauchery temporarily by giving them a Godly king. God will end our debauchery permanently with God the King. What the world saw during the 30’s is nothing compared to what we see today. God gave us prophecies to show us His grace, and that He knows and controls the future. God’s judgement is not dependent on our love and compassion, it is dependent on our belief that Christ is God and only He can make us righteous before God. (John 3:36) The whole world is on a slippery path to its end times.